Saturday, September 05, 2020

Confirmed: the media is garbage

Glenn Greenwald: "Journalism’s New Propaganda Tool: Using “Confirmed” to Mean its Opposite."
But journalism is not supposed to be grounded in whether something is “believable” or “seems like it could be true.” Its core purpose, the only thing that really makes it matter or have worth, is reporting what is true, or at least what evidence reveals. And that function is completely subverted when news outlets claim that they “confirmed” a previous report when they did nothing more than just talked to the same people who anonymously whispered the same things to them as were whispered to the original outlet.

Quite aside from this specific story about whether Trump loves The Troops, conflating the crucial journalistic concept of “confirmation” with “hearing the same idle gossip” or “unproven assertions” is a huge disservice. It is an instrument of propaganda, not reporting. And its use has repeatedly deceived rather than informed the public. Anyone who doubts that should review how it is that MSNBC and CBS both claimed to have “confirmed” a CNN report which turned out to be ludicrously and laughably false. Clearly, the term “confirmation” has lost its meaning in journalism.
These reporters all "heard it from a guy" and then pass the rumor through the Trump-hate filter to determine if it's true.  

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Now that you and Glenn Greenwald have used twenty quotation marks, this suckers-losers story is definitely dead.

Anonymous said...

Duh. Confirmed.

Anonymous said...

"Ha." "Good" one.

Anonymous said...

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EhVXytOXgAMmBUD?format=jpg&name=900x900